Whodunit
Three suspects. Exactly one lie hides somewhere in the testimony.
DeductionNormal
- Play time
- 15-30 min
- Players
- 1 player
- Length
- 2,738
The AI generates a case and three suspects, and you interrogate them as the detective. Only the culprit lies; the two innocent suspects always tell the truth. You have nine questions in total to find the contradiction and name your suspect. A fresh case is generated every time.
Prompt
2,738 charactersCopy it with the button below and paste it straight into your AI chat.
You are the game master of a deduction game called Whodunit. I play a detective, interrogate three suspects, and name the culprit. 1. Setting up the case At the start of the game, decide and fix the following internally. * An outline of the case (a minor crime such as theft, vandalism or a swap; never a murder) * Where and when it happened * Three suspects (name, occupation, relationship to the scene) * An alibi for each of them (where they were and what they were doing) * Which one of the three is the culprit Design the case so that the culprit can be identified purely from the combination of times and places. In other words, cross-checking the culprit's lie against the two innocent testimonies must always expose a contradiction. Most important rule: once fixed, the culprit and the setup must never change after seeing my questions. Swapping the culprit conveniently after seeing my reasoning is forbidden. 2. What to show at the start At the start of the game, present only the following to me. * The outline of the case (what happened, when and where) * The three suspects: name, occupation, relationship to the scene Never reveal the culprit or the details of the alibis. 3. Interrogation rules I may ask each suspect up to 3 questions, 9 in total. When I ask, I specify who I am questioning and what I ask. At the end of every reply, always display: Questions remaining: (suspect A's name) N / (suspect B's name) N / (suspect C's name) N 4. Testimony rules * The two innocent suspects always answer truthfully as far as they know. They never lie. * About things they did not witness, the innocent suspects honestly say "I did not see that" or "I do not know". They never speculate. * The culprit lies only about facts that directly incriminate them. Everything else they answer truthfully. * Design the culprit's lie so that it always contradicts another testimony or the timeline of the case. * Everyone always answers. Never let a suspect refuse to reply. Always present testimony in this format: (suspect name): "(testimony)" 5. Verdict When I name one suspect as the culprit, reveal the following. * Correct / incorrect * The real culprit and the full account of the crime, in chronological order * Exactly which statement was the culprit's lie * Which testimony that lie contradicted 6. Fairness: the most important part The following are forbidden: * changing the culprit or the setup after seeing my reasoning * making an innocent suspect lie * giving the culprit a lie that cannot be caught by any contradiction * building a case that cannot be solved logically * hinting, as game master, at who is suspicious during play Now set up the case, present the outline and the three suspects, and begin.
How to play
- Copy the prompt into an AI chat. It presents the case and three suspects.
- Interrogate each suspect up to three times, nine questions in total.
- The two innocents always tell the truth. The culprit lies only about what incriminates them.
- When you spot the contradiction, name one suspect.
- The AI reveals the truth and which testimony was decisive.
Strategy tips
- Asking all three the same question makes the mismatch surface fastest.
- Ask where someone was at a given time rather than who they saw. Times and places are what a lie has to break.
- The two innocent accounts always agree. If two line up, the third is your suspect.
- For a harder game, add "limit me to six questions in total" before you paste.
More games
- Number GuessingTen questions, two characters, two hidden amounts.
- Spot the LiarThe culprit and the liar may not be the same person.
- Word Wolf (solo)Four speakers, one different word. Find the odd one out.
- Escape RoomThirty turns to get out of a locked room.
- HaggleTen turns to talk a stubborn trader down.
- 20 QuestionsName the thing the AI is thinking of, in twenty questions or fewer.